2020 Volume 11 Issue 1 Special Issue
Creative Commons License

A Comparative study between the I-gel and the Endotracheal Tube in Patients Going Through the ‎Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy‎ ‎ ‎


Mitra Golmohammadi, Alireza Mahoori, Shahryar Sane*, Shiva Pakzad, Hale Ahmadi ‎‎‎
Abstract

Background: Because the I-gel as a supraglotic airway devices can produce high oropharyngeal ‎seal pressure and also gastric decompression, have been used in patients who would have been ‎usually intubated for general anesthesia, This study was designed to compare safety and ‎efficacy I-gel with tracheal tube in patients undergoing laparoscopic cholecystectomy.‎ Materials & Methods: Sixty  patients, class I or II ASA, who  were candidates for elective ‎cholecystectomy recruited to this study to one of the two groups of 30 patients each; with either ‎I-gel or tracheal tube as their airway device. Ease, and the number of attempts for insertion of ‎airway device, the difference between the inspired and expired tidal volumes, which was ‎calculate as the leak volume. The leak fraction was defined as the leak volume divided by the ‎inspired tidal volume, were recorded and compared among two groups. ‎Results: The first attempt success rate was similar with both I-gel and tracheal tube. There was ‎significant difference between the leak volume of the i-gel and the tracheal tube ‎groups(p=0.001).We had also found significant difference in leak fraction(p=0.001).Despite ‎these significant different, ventilation and oxygenation was optimal in both of two groups. ‎ETCO2 during C02 pneumoperitoneum was between two groups was not significant (p=0.78). ‎The airway pressure among I-gel group and tracheal tube group during C02 pneumoperitoneum ‎was significantly different(p=0.04). Sore throat was significantly higher in tracheal tube group ‎than I-gel group (p=0.02). ‎Conclusion:‎‏ ‏The results of this study demonestrated that the I-gel is a valuable substitute to ‎endotracheal intubation for controlled ventilation during laparoscopic cholecystectomy‎‎.


Issue 2 Volume 16 - 2025